Anasayfa Polemik İnceleme   Büktel Hakkında     Linkler İletişim

 

 (For a Büktel biography, in English, please CLİCK!)

 

SİNEMA

 

"Gönül Yarası" ("Lovelorn") (2005)

 

Coşkun Büktel’in, International Movie Data Base (imdb.com) sitesinde

yayınlanmış sinema yorumları:

Yavuz Turgul'un “Gönül Yarası” filmi hakkında:

 

(Cinema comments of Coşkun Büktel published in imdb.com

About “GÖNÜL YARASI  ("LOVELORN")

directed by YAVUZ TURGUL:

 

 

 

THE TURKISH VERSION OF "ENOUGH"

26th January 2007

 

Sener Sen is perfect. Meltem Cumbul plays not her film character but a
crafty player playing her character. Timucin Esen is perfect. Director
Yavuz Turgul's story seems to be borrowed from Michael Apted's "Enough" (starring Jennifer Lopez and scripted by Nicholas Kazan). Both "Gonul Yarasi" and "Enough" have the same storyline, in which an oppressed woman ill treated by her psychopathic husband runs away from him taking her (and his) child with her.

It may be said that there is no part for Sener Sen in "Enough". Well,
there is no need for the part of Sener Sen in "Gonul Yarasi", either.
Everything narrated and shown about the character Sen plays is just secondary and does not support the main plot of Gonul Yarasi. Yavuz Turgul could easily omit Sen's character from the story and better focus his camera on Cumbul/Esen relation. In that case, the character of Sumer Tılmaç would get a little larger and deeper and could include (only when necessary) Sen's part, too.

Although the name of Sener Sen is written on the top of the cast, although the camera sees him more frequently than any other character; "Gonul Yarasi" is essentially Cumbul's and Esen's story (the implied love between Sen and Cumbul is just a rifle which never fires in the story) and Sener Sen is just a helpless witness unable to do anything to change the course and the finale of the main plot which is also the main plot of "Enough".

But in order to make justice towards Turgul, we must declare that despite the flaws of the plot (for example, in a more credible script, the psychopathic husband wouldn't tolerate for one moment Sen's giving Cumbul shelter at his home and living together with her under the same roof) "Gonul Yarasi" is much better a film than "Enough" in many ways including credibility and artistic quality.

 

 

COŞKUN BÜKTEL'İN SİNEMA YORUMLARI

Cinema-comments of Büktel:

 

(About) Yavuz Turgul's Gönül Yarası (coskunbuktel.com)

"Lovelorn"  (imdb.com)

The Turkish version of "Enough" (coskunbuktel.com)

26 Ocak (January) 2007

 

(About) Rene Clement's “Plein Soleil” (imdb.com)

"Purple Noon" or "Kızgın Güneş" as we title it in Turkey (coskunbuktel.com)

22 Aralık (December) 2005
 

 

(About) Philip Leacock's “Spanish Gardener” (imdb.com)

Just a little correction about Cronin (coskunbuktel.com)

7 Nisan (April) 2006

 

(About) Ahmet Uluçay's "Karpuz Kabuğundan Gemiler Yapmak" "Boats Out of Watermelon Rinds" (imdb.com)

It is unjust to call it "A sort of Cinema Paradiso" (coskunbuktel.com)

5 Haziran (June) 2006

 

(About) Carmine Gallone's “Michel Strogoff” (imdb.com)

One of my almost forgotten nostalgia (coskunbuktel.com)

22 Aralık (December) 2006

 

 

(For a Büktel biography, in English, please CLİCK!)